Well the gunsmith at our store is a Marine Corps certified AR 15 armorer with about 40 years experience and I'm a retired mechainical engineer that is also a certifed AR 15 armorer by several of the companies whose products we sell at the same store.
As I stated in my above posts we tried and checked all areas, magazines, components etc., etc., for problems.
We had gone thru all of the questionable areas such as component clearance and fit up, 7 different magazines while trying all sorts of ammo combinations. The gas key was torqued to spec and the gas path clear and un-obstructed. All that was left was the gas system was not getting enough gas pressure to cycle the action.
When the gas system was torn down, the main issue that was found was the undersize .81 inch gas orifice diameter in the barrel. Armalite specs are .084 minimum diameter. When the gas orifice diameter was drilled out to .084 inches the rifle run 6 of 10 rounds without short cycling. I made the decision to open up the diameter to .093 and the gun will run with all types of ammo.
In the scheme of things, opening up the gas port was the last thing that was done to modify the rifle so it would function.
I would think that we followed an extremely logical approach to find and correct the issue with out undue cost and with a minimum amount time and BS.