Jump to content
308AR.com Community
  • Visit Aero Precision
  • Visit Brownells
  • Visit EuroOptic
  • Visit Site
  • Visit Beachin Tactical
  • Visit Rainier Arms
  • Visit Ballistic Advantage
  • Visit Palmetto State Armory
  • Visit Cabelas
  • Visit Sportsmans Guide

MEC 's new Single stage Press


survivalshop

Recommended Posts

On 1/7/2017 at 10:10 PM, planeflyer21 said:

I wonder if the floating case holder sort of "wiggles" the case out of the sizing die, as opposed to brute "yanking" of a fixed holder, allowing the brass to stay put instead of flowing.

 

10 hours ago, planeflyer21 said:

I still think it's this.

   Wiggles may not be the correct word for it . The Case , be it inserted into the Die for sizing or retracted after sizing , is under a bit of pressure , less on retraction , but still under pressure , add to that that the inside of the Neck of the casing is actually being finished sized on retraction of the case from the Die .

  Wiggles may sum it up in a way , but more likely its a realignment of the case or with the floating Shell Holder ,permitting realignment , where as a fixed secure or locked in Shell Holder , its not permitted to do this aligning & any out of alignment of the case , its being forced through it .

  If you have a Dillon , with the Tool head , you will notice ( maybe by design ) that the whole Tool Head floats & may accomplish the same thing as a floating Shell Holder , with an added benefit of all processes , be it sizing , Seating of the Bullet or what ever form of Crimping is done .

 I wasn't going to purchase a concentricity gage , but may now , just to see if the case is formed abnormally in some way . The one I 'am looking at is the Sinclair one . I have a couple extra Dial indicators & this can be purchased with out one , for less $$.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 65
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

 I ordered the Sinclair concentricity gage from Brownells with the Dial indicator , it was on sale for $ 99.99 & free shipping . The reviews read that the Dial Indicator is Chinese , but I have a good one to replace it with if I don't like it &  if it fits .

Curiosity is not cheap sometimes .

Edited by survivalshop
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

 Well I have found an issue with my new MEC press when installing my new Forster Match Seating Die . After setting the Die up & seating my first Bullet into a 308 Case , I felt the same type of rubbing as I did with the RCBS Die & found that the 308 Case was binding in the Die . If you look at the pictures of how a Forster Seating Die works , it has a spring loaded guide for keeping the Case & Bullet aligned in with the process of Seating the Bullet . 

 It looks like the Ram of the press is not aligned with the Die , if I keep the Shell holder with the Case feed opening toward me , it binds& scraps the side of the case , if I turn the Shell Holder 180 deg. , so the opening to insert the Case in the Shell Holder is in the back , the Case is moved out or over to allow the Case to move or slide so as not to bind .

 After this I started to look it over a lot closer , & sure enough , that Ram will not line up with any Brand Die I own or Shell Holder for that matter . I tried four different Shell holder from three different manufacturers . I emailed MEC with my issue & will let update this thread . That will teach me to get one of the first ones off the production line .

 This is also probably why I was scraping the Bullets in the RCBS Die's Roll Crimp ring . 

 Also brings back mrmackc 's words on his experience with MEC .

Edited by survivalshop
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Whats real funny is , most of the Brass sized is dead on with my Concentricity Gage , some are way off , different brands , I find that odd . I have heard of issues with RCBS of late also , suppose to be made oversea's . 

 I did get one of the first ones , the ones they sent to the writers , probably got the once over .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, survivalshop said:

 Whats real funny is , most of the Brass sized is dead on with my Concentricity Gage , some are way off , different brands , I find that odd . I have heard of issues with RCBS of late also , suppose to be made oversea's

 I did get one of the first ones , the ones they sent to the writers , probably got the once over .

There was a BIG f-ing stink a few years back.  People buying Rock Crusher kits had presses cast in China.  People were NOT happy about that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Press is in UPS's hands & got a call from an engineering company for MEC this morning & talked about my issue , I told him I may have found the issue & it may not be the Ram . When I removed the Press from the bench I got to looking at the Threaded insert for the Die's , that is pressed or something into the Casting of the Press Body & it looks Cocked in the Press casting . Don't know if it moved or was that way from the get go .also has a wear mark right above that high side , like the Die Lock ring has worn a spot .

 He also told me he is going to pull a Press & give it a once over before they send it to me today .

DSCN2835.JPG

Edited by survivalshop
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  The sized brass from this press that I finished loading on the Pacific Press were odd to me , some were perfect , almost all the LC once fired had about 0.002" run out on the Brass & the same with the seated bullet , almost perfect , but most others brands were over 0.005" & some went to 0.017"  ,which is almost bent , at least thats the way it felt going into the Forster Seating Die . 

 I don't quite understand this , why would they all not be way out , in terms of run out ? I will have the new press tomorrow , so I can see how this works out with a new true press . 

 What will be interesting , is shooting the true run out ammo to the ammo that is way off , just to see what , if any , difference in grouping , velocity , ES & SD . All ammo is the same weighed charge , same primer , Bullet & COL .

 Why the LC brass came out Ok is a brain scratcher . Makes me think I did something differently or wrong or right , just strange . input , not that it really matters , unless the new one does the same :lmao:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, MikedaddyH said:

SS, it seems that this press was a lesson. 

MEC should stick to shotgun shells.

Is it too late to trade this press in on one of their shotgun shell reloaders ? Jmho.

But then he'd have to get a semi-auto shotgun to justify it.  Oh, yeah.

SS maybe you should trade this one in one a MEC shotgun shell reloader.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

    New one came today & is smooth , Threaded insert is flush all the way around & it sizes the LC once fired brass to with in 0.001" , run out , on all my test brass & then the seated Bullets ( 155SMK ) all had a run out less then 0.001" ( the needle barely moved ) , which actually could be Bullet or brass imperfections , especially with the Brass , so I think I will keep this Press .

 I also found that the run out on even the ammo loaded on the other press & on the Pacific Press , lost on average  0.001" Bullet run out ,after Taper Crimping , not saying for sure that a Taper Crimp will straighten out some of the Bullet alignment , but its looks like a possibility . I will have to try the Lee FCD out & see what it does . Interesting . 

  The Concentricity Gage has made me a monster !     The sleeper has awakened !:laffs:

Edited by survivalshop
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 I got one of the first production ones out there . I got unlucky & got a defected one or one that made it past inspection . Who knows , they were very fast in replacing it & top notch Customer service , as good as any of there big name Manufacturers I have dealt with . I have had to send Dies back , parts breakage on my Bullet sizer & small other thing with reloading with the Big Name Manufacturers , so I wont hold it against this Manufacturer . 

   $hit happens & they took care of me as good as you can get . This is my first MEC product & since it has already proved to me it has great potential for a reloader . I will be doing a lot of testing with my new Concentricity gage on different factory loads , Match that I have & different Reloads for comparison , but this Press & maybe the Forster Match Seating Die seem to be a good combo .

 I did do some of my older Hand loads & as my other thread showed , most were 0.004-5" Run out , on average , to get 0.001" on average has to have an effect on Bullet performance , this is a whole new path to go down for me , might not pan out to prove anything , but I can't help thinking , any time you get a Bullet not dead nuts aligned with the Bore or Lead , it has to have some effect on its performance .

 I'm breaking out the big boy for testing , the  Krieger/Criterion 20"HB . 

 

Edited by survivalshop
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  There is a difference from the first Press in a couple of ways , the threaded insert for the Die's & the Clip that retains the floating Shell Holder .

Look closely at how the ( in this case an old RCBS Green Machine expander body for a Little Dandy Powder Measurer ) Die Body is tilted in the Threaded Insert & the clip that retains the SH is not straight across .

DSCN2831.JPG

This is the New press , with Shell holder & a Redding Bushing type , Full length Sizing Die 

DSCN2843.JPG

And a photo of the Threaded insert for the Die's ( old )

DSCN2835.JPG

New 

DSCN2841.JPG

 I cleaned & sized about fifty LC today & they are in the Tumbler with SS ,as I type . These will be my test bed to compare with ammo loaded on the Pacific , both with fixed Shell Holder & Floating .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 I sized 50+ once fired surplus LC 308's yesterday & all came out with very little run out , very consistent for brass supposedly fired from a worn out Belt fed . They are so nice & pretty after the SS tumble .

  I first thought that that Threaded insert moved from Sizing 308 LC surplus Brass , but the paint on that Insert was not disturbed as it would if it moved after it was painted , it just looked like it just was missed by Quality Control . The Engineers emailed me yesterday to ask me how it was going , nice they do a follow up .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

     Finished loading 52 rounds for testing that were completely loaded from start to finish on the new MEC press , Redding Bushing, Full length sizing Die & Forster Match Seating Die & Taper crimped , none of them had a run out over 0.002", most as tested were in the 0.001" range constantly  , I tested some Milspec 308 ( 7.62x51 ) both LC & some of the Copper washed Russian crap & none were under 0.005" run out . 

     Looks like I shot up all the Match ammo , its where I got the Match brass from I guess , strange I can't find any Chrono . data , but I only had five rounds each from various manufacturers to test . I did find some factory WW , Nickel Case & a Black Bullet ( Moly coated ? ) , I got from 0.0025 - 0.005" run out on just five of them & all but the one had 0.005" run out . 
      I started to test my older ( if you can call them that ) Hand Loads & some of them went any where from 0.005-0.011" run out . These were loaded with 175 Gr. Nosler Match , 168 gr. Nosler Match , 168 gr. Hornady Amax  & 168 gr. Hornady Match Bullets loaded . I'm kinda wondering if it the Bullet can have imperfections & some of the run out deviations ,it could be , but I just can't see it all being the Bullet , because when the case neck is tested for run out before seating the Bullet ,the run out is about the same after seating the Bullet .

      I think this New MEC , with its floating Shell Holder , combined with the Dies being used , makes a more detailed loaded round , now I wonder if my old Pacific Press has anything to do with the large run out in the loaded round & case Necks , after all , all these reloads were loaded with a fixed Shell Holder in the Pacific Press , but not with the Forster Seating Die .

As far as how it shoots , well that will hopefully happen tomorrow . 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...