Good points MM and 98. Where did you get the brass? I am guessing it might have been loaded more than once, and maybe to near max loads. You mentioned loading to a lighter load, but as you used a different powder, that is comparing apples to oranges. Can't really compare the two charges. Interesting that 98's data on starting loads from the Hornady Manuals for CFE223 were tremendously different from what I found on Hodgdon's web page. Were the primer pockets swaged of their crimps when you got the brass? If it was once fired military, the primer crimp would be intact, but if it had already been reloaded, they would have had to swage out the crimp to put a second primer in. If that is the case, it has been loaded at least twice. All my older military brass I lighten the powder charge a little and use for range plinking. I save my once fired newer brass for when I want to seriously shoot.